Director Frank Capra, who died in 1991, was not known
as a futurist, but he was one.
"It's a Wonderful Life" is his
best-known work. Yet in thumbing through a dandy new book that recalls an
area of his moviemaking not often cited, I've been noting how prophetic he
and his writers were when creating crises and conflicts for their many
media characters.
The book is "Frank Capra and the Image of the
Journalist in American Film." On the cover, in the 1934 movie "It Happened
One Night," is Clark Gable as hard-boiled New York Mail reporter Pete
Warne ("Hey, listen, monkey face; when you fired me, you fired the best
newshound your filthy scandal sheet ever had"). Yeah, that's the way we
all talk. The author is Joe Saltzman, a first-rate news documentarian and
a professor and associate dean in USC's Annenberg School for
Communication.
Although his focus is Capra's screen work, Saltzman
at one point widens his commentary to images of journalists in all movies,
including a category of jerk with whom some of you may be
familiar.
"Critics," writes Saltzman about movie portrayals of
these heartless newspaper cads, "often write columns as well as reviews,
and many are cold-blooded, unscrupulous journalists who use their power to
get what they want when they want it and collect their pound of flesh
whenever they feel like it."
And that's bad?
The drama
critic in Capra's 1944 adaptation of "Arsenic and Old Lace" would be
insufferable "if he wasn't played so ingratiatingly by Cary Grant," notes
Saltzman in his book (which can be purchased through the Web site www.ijpc
.org).
But no Capra journalists are gleaming heroes, which Saltzman
believes may be a genesis of today's broad mistrust of media. It's not
such a wonderful life for his newshounds. They're flawed, from Stew Smith
(Robert Williams), who drinks too much in "Platinum Blonde" (1931), to Diz
Moore (Thomas Mitchell), who drinks too much in "Mr. Smith Goes to
Washington" (1939), to columnist Ann Mitchell (Barbara Stanwyck), who
doesn't drink too much in "Meet John Doe" (1941). All she does is
fabricate a story.
"Capra's editors and reporters may do terrible
things, but they're really nice guys," Saltzman said this week. The Big
Nasties lurk elsewhere. One reason Saltzman chose Capra as a subject "was
that he was so ahead of his time in realizing who the real villains of
journalism were." And? "All of the vicious villains in Capra films were
tycoons," Saltzman said. "What Capra and Robert Riskin [the writer who was
his primary collaborator] predicted is how the media would be controlled
by them."
He's speaking now of today's sprawling archipelagos of
media interests. The gargantuan ones are AOL Time Warner, Viacom Inc.,
Walt Disney Co. and Rupert Murdoch's News Corp., each having potential,
through their splayed radii of communications, to manipulate the
information we receive and control what we think and think about. On a
smaller scale, but right there with them, is this paper's
media-conglomerate owner, Tribune Co.
As media critic Mark Crispin
Miller has written:
"The true cause of the enormous ills that now
dismay so many Americans--the universal sleaze and 'dumbing down,' the
flood-tide of corporate propaganda, the terminal insanity of United States
politics--has risen not from any grand decline in national character ...
but from the inevitable toxic influence of those few corporations that
have monopolized our culture."
Speaking as a monopolizer, I plead
guilty. Even if Miller is overstating a bit, though, the trend of growing
influence by a few corporations--that own movies, book publishing,
magazines, newspapers, over-the-air television, cable and you name it--is
extremely troubling.
What would Capra do about it if he were making
movies today? "He'd go after AOL Time Warner, Disney and all the rest,"
Saltzman said. "He'd probably make a movie with a TV reporter, someone at
a local station, showing how people there were fighting against a
takeover."
In other words, Capra opposed centering media control in
fewer and fewer hands, which at once widens the reach of the messenger and
narrows and homogenizes the message. "That attitude was a key part of his
thinking in the '30s and '40s," Saltzman said. "He was afraid of this
control of the media."
Even though the vast bulk of Capra's films
were made before the TV era, and his journalists largely mirrored
newspaper cliches of the time, their reflections of expanding power in
media boardrooms apply more than ever.
Released in 1948 and based
on a stage play, for example, "State of the Union" has Spencer Tracy as a
presidential candidate who makes compromises and alters his values to
accommodate the ambitions of a ruthless newspaper publisher (Angela
Lansbury) and political boss (Adolphe Menjou).
Saltzman finds the
1941 tycoon in "Meet John Doe" even more wicked. Facing dismissal from her
job, it's Stanwyck's Mitchell who does the unthinkable by inventing in her
newspaper column a letter from a John Doe who vows to commit suicide on
Christmas Eve to protest the misery, corruption and hypocrisy suffocating
him. It's despotic new publisher D.B. Norton (Edward Arnold), however, who
is Capra's epic scoundrel here, because Mitchell would not be writing her
dishonest column of protest had he not bought the paper and given her and
her colleagues pink slips in pursuit of his dream: a fascist
U.S.
It's not fascism that dominates today's headlines. If Capra
were alive and active today, would he want to make a movie showing
reporters covering combat in Afghanistan or the Middle East instead of
filming their combat with editors and moguls? Only one Capra film, "Here
Comes the Groom" in 1951, includes a foreign correspondent (played by, uh,
Bing Crosby). "He stayed away from foreign correspondents," Saltzman
said.
Instead, Capra quit Hollywood during World War II and made
seven documentaries for the War Department. So Saltzman thinks Capra would
now be offering his services to the government, this time to again make
documentaries "about why we fight."
Not only terrorism, but the
narrowing of media diversity.
*
Howard Rosenberg's column
appears Mondays and Fridays. He can be contacted at howard.rosenberg
@latimes.com.






